A few people asked for it, so here it is!
*WARNING SPOILER ALERT!!!*
Okay, so I used to have some really fancy and balanced scale here, but its just annoying to do that. And out of 10 makes more sense. So, here it is.
Pokemon Black and White are really awesome. All of the Pokemon games are. Combine JRPGs, strategy, and mathematics and you have a genius game that is one of the few video games that is played competitively over simulators. As you probably don’t know, I play this rather awesome game competitively over simulators. Still don’t believe me that Pokemon is really all that mathematical and strategical ish and stuff? Damage Formula = (((((((Level × 2 ÷ 5) + 2) × BasePower × [Sp]Atk ÷ 50) ÷ [Sp]Def) × Mod1) + 2) ×
CH × Mod2 × R ÷ 100) × STAB × Type1 × Type2 × Mod3) That’s a formula it uses. So there!!
So, since I play Pokemon competitively (though not over the game but on simulators), it made sense for me to import the game in September rather than wait 6-8 months. Which, since they looked so awesome, I didn’t want to do. So, I have the Japanese version and beat it abouuutttt- 5 months ago? So, really, I guess I’ve had 5 months to think about how I’m going to rate it.
Graphics
Okay, the graphics of this game are amazing. This is EXACTLY what Pokemon Diamond and Pearl should’ve been like, though, which is the sad thing- the DS was outdated 6 years ago when it came out. For all you people complaining about crappy graphics- is it REALLY the game’s fault? The only way to have good graphics is to use a fancy style, which would not fit pokemon at all. And I hear complaints of “The pokemon aren’t in 3d!!!!”. Have you ever looked at pokemon fanart on the internet? How many different pokemon personalities there are? Try imagining all of those in 3d. I personally cannot do that. I see one image- a personality-less pokemon. Which is good for things like Pokemon Stadium, but definitely not for a DS pokemon game where personality and cuteness/coolness in a pokemon really matter. 3d figures take away almost all of the personality. At least the sprites are animated, but they should’ve been exactly like that in Diamond and Pearl, which is yet again a sad thing. Also, I would have loved to see it where my Boiling Water attack does not come from my Purinu (the water octopus guy, YES I KNOW I SPELLED THE NAME WRONG.)’s forehead, but rather his mouth. And when a pokemon uses fly or something, they flap their wings. And when they use surf, you see them move with the wave. That’s kinda dissapointing, but you can’t complain too much about what’s not there when what is there isn’t too bad. It just seems like a game that comes out as a FINAL NINTENDO FRANCHISE DS GAME would have this dissapointing graphics. But, they are still pretty good. But, they are still dissapointing at the same time. I want a first person pokemon game. Remember Metroid Prime Hunters and how good of a tech-thing that was? WHY couldn’t Pokemon, released SIX YEARS LATER have that good of graphics! Really. So, overall, I will give graphics… 7.8/10
Sound/Music
The sound and music of pokemon games are always amazing in their own right, with Black and White being no exception. If you came here expecting the same amazing soundtrack Silver and Gold offered, you’ll be out of luck but it still is better than Diamond, Pearl, Ruby, and Sapphire (the last few pokemon games.). Seriously, for those of you who have the game, LISTEN TO THE TEAM PLASMA THEME! IT IS THE BESTEST. The main battle theme is a bit dissapointing, though. The wild pokemon battle is too. If these would’ve been good, than Pokemon Black and White’s soundtrack would’ve been the best in the series. But sadly, since you listen to them so much, Pokemon Black and White are harmed a bit by the poor wild pokemon and main battle themes. Every single pokemon game to date has had better wild pokemon and main battle themes. But, Pokemon Black and White BEAT every other pokemon game in soundtracks OTHER than that. The gym leader theme is absolutely amazing. As is the Team Plasma theme. And the low hp theme. And the last pokemon Gym Leader theme. You really need to hear these! I’d rank Black and White second to Gold and Silver when it comes to soundtrack, which earns them an 8.8/10! (that would be a 10/10 if the battle.. and wild.. pokemon.. themes.. were… actually… GOOD!)
Gameplay
The gameplay is the same as before. Without this, Pokemon is not Pokemon. People don’t realize that. “WELL I WANT TO ADD ANOTHER TYPE!” That would be admitadly cool but it would mess up the entire competitive type balance. Pokemon cannot be touched how it is- triple battles and rotation battles are new, but not really that cool. But, here’s the thing- Pokemon was NEVER broke. So, it NEVER needed fixing. And that’s the case now. “Fixing” pokemon would just break it. It does disapoint me that its the same “Trainer named ___ on their first journey in the region ____ trying to gather the 8 badges and fight evil team ___ and defeat the elite four and catch the legendary ____” as always, but that made the japanese game much easier to understand, so not many complaints there for me. The new pokemon are amazing. The starters are crap, but the rest are amazing. The water octopus is the best, and so is Sazandora (The pseudo-legendary dark dragon hydra.) and I love my Muurando (the dog.). If you’ve noticed, I am not calling them by their English names. Why is this? Because the English names are AWFUL! Oshawatt? REALLY? Revolver Oshawatt GO! And Tepig? Wow. Take “Tepid” and add a “g” and be clever, right? Sounds VERY intellegent. Pignite is the middle form, and the fan predicted name. I like Pignite. SNIVY is also an awful name. Smugleaf, the fan name, is cooler. Some of them aren’t bad, like Lillup, but YoTerrie (ther japanese name) is much cooler. I guess I’ll get used to it though. The game is really fun though. The region is pretty cool, and so is the entire new “world” they created. However, Red is not at the end. Instead, you have Cynthia and Morimoto who I swept with one wild pokemon that you catch at level 75, a bug fire moth, that knows Butterfly Dance (raises Sp. Attack, Sp. Def, and Speed all one stage) Heat Wave, and Bug Buzz. So, Cynthia and Morimoto are easy- they stupidly let you get 4 Butterfly dances and SWEEP. Yeah. There is also no 8 more gym leaders, but I guess I’m starting to get into the game’s replay value?? 9.5/10
Replay Value
There are 8 gyms. There is virtually nothing to do after you beat the game other than the battle subway. And the game is short. There aren’t cities in between gyms. There are only about 10 cities before the Elite Four, and the first two are, you guessed it, the cities before the first gym. And while the cities are some of the coolest cities yet (Hiun has a population over 600, more than the entire population of the region Kanto. It also has 360-type stuff impossible to describe unless you play the game.), the cities aren’t spaced out very well. There are 3 cities after the Elite Four, but what motive is there? You have to remember game design theory. It isn’t good to have no motivation or reward- ONE city has motivation- you can fight Cynthia there. But once you fight her, and cream her with your Buttterfly Moth Fire Bug thing, what else do you do? The last 3 cities are absolutely awful, like they were built in 10 seconds and just thrown in there. White Forest is pretty good, but really there isn’t much reward for building up your forest. Had these cities been fully fleshed out and made cool (like the city in Sapphire and Ruby where everone lived in trees that were connected with vine branches!!), that would’ve had a bit more motivation. Also, the cities are ridiculously small. The rest of Unova (Black and White’s region) is pretty big, with 2 cities being bigger than the biggest city in all the other regions. So, you have 3 small, ugly, villages for the player to “explore” after they beat the game. VERY EXCITING! What GENIUS game design, Game Freak! Here’s what they should’ve done- put a very experienced trainer with level 80′s and a reasonable strategy and great AI (sort of like Red but a bit less epic and a bit better at battling) in each of the 3 cities (Cynthia has 70′s, no reasonable strategy, and awful AI.) with side plots required to get them all and extra bonuses and a HUGE CITY TO EXPLORE TO GET THEM. I just wonder, Gold and Silver were done on little tiny, hardly any memory, GAMEBOY CARTRIDGES. They were GAMEBOY GAMES. That played on a piece of machinery FROM THE 80′s. They played on a 20 year old machine, and yet are twice as long as the more recent pokemon games? That bothers me. The only reason Gold and Silver weren’t any bigger was because they physically couldn’t be! Every single byte on that cartridge is filled up to the maximum. Nintendo also didn’t make cartridges with more space than that. So, if a DS cart can fit an entire nintendo 64 game (Mario 64) with BONUS content (The 3 added characters and multiplayer mode) couldn’t a DS cart fit, I don’t know, as much STUFF as Gold and Silver? I gaurentee you that the cartridge is not maxed out. They did not run out of space. They got LAZY. And its not like a second region would need to be as detailed as the first- Kanto added 10 hours to Gold and Silver with virtually every aspect of it removed. Kanto was NOTHING yet it added 10 hours of fun beating the gym leaders and beating Red. Soul Silver and Heart Gold did it, but Gold and Silver had already done the exact same thing before. And I know for a fact that the actual mapping of the game and creating of new trainers doesn’t take very long- I would have gladly waited an extra year for them to add another region, or even Hoenn or Sinnoh! At that point, they could also fix the poor graphics too with the 3ds! But, sadly, Pokemon Black and White aren’t what they could’ve been. I feel kinda silly complaining about a 40 hour quest, though, but it has nothing on Silver and Gold’s 80 hour quest. 7/10.
Overallllllll……
9/10. Pokemon Black and White are definitely not the games they should’ve been, but that doesn’t mean they aren’t good in their own respect. But, right now, which game do you think I’m on my 20-somethingth-replay of? Pokemon White? No, Pokemon Silver. Pokemon Black/White could’ve been much more, but they are pretty good.
And the dream world is awesome, I don’t really want to spoil the initial excitement for you guys.
And the C-Gear, same as above.
And when you reach the middle Island of Unova…
Basically, its still Pokemon, its just not the next step forwards for the series but rather an awkward step diagonal-sideways, if that makes sense.
Highly reccommended for anyone, and I think this is probably the 2nd best pokemon game to start with (1st = Silver. If you want to fork out the money for a working copy.)
Goodbye DS! I really loved your Swan Song, though it dissapointed me at the same time. Here’s a Haiku.
I got you day one
And I beat all of your games
But now you’re boring
And here’s another one to continue-
And you’re graphics are
More outdated than ever
And you’re games? Lazy.
And the last one-
Next? The 3ds.
Probably won’t fix problems.
BUT it will be good.
Hope you enjoyed this review!
Bug
SocialVibe